FILM
The Ninth Guest
1934
MYSTERY
1hr 5mn

I try hard not to read synopses or watch trailers prior to viewing a movie. So why was I experiencing deja vu in the first 15 minutes of Ninth Guest? A few minutes later the been-here-done-that feeling turned into a flat realization: “Oh! This is a rip-off of Agatha Christie’s 'And Then There Were None!'" But wait! Christie’s book came later. Huh? Draw your own conclusions. As far as the two films are concerned, they’re both entertaining but I prefer “Guest.” “None’s” Barry Fitzgerald is a tiresome, typecast leprechaun. “Guest’s” set design and wardrobe is a tribute to art deco of the period. Both casts hold up their end of the bargain but “Guest’s” dialogue is between party goers familiar with one another and its penthouse setting makes it the winner.

CAST: Donald Cook, Genevieve Tobin, Hardie Albright
DIRECTED BY: Roy William Neill
WRITERS: Owen Davis, Gwen Bristow, Bruce Manning
For Consideration
Gosford Park
2001
HUMAN RELATIONS
2hr 17mn
A Double Life
1947
PSYCHODRAMA
1hr 44mn
House on Telegraph Hill
1951
SUSPENSE
1hr 33mn
Ace in the Hole
1951
HUMAN NATURE
1hr 51mn